Costs and ROI
What manual order entry really costs a UK wholesaler, and how to work out the ROI of automating it
Manual order entry costs a wholesaler the hours its staff spend typing in orders, multiplied by what those staff cost to employ. Work it out with four numbers: orders a week, minutes per order, weeks worked and fully loaded hourly cost. Compare the value of the hours automation removes with the build price. The result is capacity released, not cash saved, unless you decide what to do with the hours.
It is twenty past six and the office is empty apart from Linda and the overtime sheet she has just signed. Sandra’s name is on it again. Linda turns over an envelope and starts writing. By her reckoning Sandra types about 300 orders a week into Sage 50, from emails and PDFs. Linda once stood behind her and watched one. It took four minutes. Three hundred times four is twelve hundred minutes. Twenty hours a week, half of Sandra, spent typing out what a customer has already typed. Linda has been trying to hire a second order processor since the spring. She writes “20 hrs x £?” and stops, because she does not know what an hour of Sandra costs.
Linda and Sandra are made up, and their numbers are assumptions we carry through this post. The sum works on yours.
If you would rather type your numbers into a calculator than follow the arithmetic here, use the Better Systems Co. ROI calculator. It applies the same formula and labels every assumption.
Key facts
- Better Systems Co.’s ROI formula: hours a year = tasks a week × minutes each ÷ 60 × 48 working weeks; value = hours × fully loaded hourly cost.
- Sales order processor roles in Hull were advertised at £12.21 to £15 an hour and £25,350 to £26,350 a year in 2025 (Michael Page, Adecco).
- The hours automation removes are capacity released, meaning time handed back; they only become cash saved if you change what you pay for.
- In the worked example below, 300 orders a week at 4 minutes each and £20 an hour comes to 960 hours and £19,200 a year in labour.
Why does manual order entry cost more than it looks?
Because nobody adds it up. Typing in an order takes a few minutes, sits inside somebody’s job title, and is spread across the order desk, the trade counter and, on busy days, the owner. One Sage 50 user described the work as “typing the PO and then typing the entire order out again in the SO” (Sage Community Hub). Another was “presently printing, and then typing back in to Sage” (Sage Community Hub). Neither had a line on the management accounts called “re-keying”, the trade word for typing in what somebody else has already typed. The cost hides inside salaries, so nobody compares it with the cost of removing it.
It is not a small-firm quirk. Sage’s September 2026 survey of 1,500 decision-makers at small and medium-sized UK firms found an average of 2.9 hours a week spent moving and re-entering information between systems that do not connect, which Sage puts at 19 working days and about £5,700 a year per business (Sage). That is an average across all such firms. An order desk typing in hundreds of orders a week will be well above it, which is why you should count your own.
Typing time is also only the first cost. A wrong quantity becomes a wrong pick, a re-delivery and a credit note. Those costs are harder to count, which is why this post treats them separately.
What is the formula?
ROI is return on investment, what you get back for what you spend. The cost side comes first. The formula Better Systems Co. uses for it has four inputs. It is our own, and we label it as such so that you can argue with it.
- Count the tasks a week. For order entry, that is orders typed in by hand in a typical week. Count a real week.
- Time a task in minutes. Watch three or four orders being typed in, from opening the email to saving the sales order, and take the middle value.
- Hours a year = tasks a week × minutes each ÷ 60 × 48. The 48 allows for holidays and bank holidays. Change it if your firm closes for longer.
- Value = hours a year × fully loaded hourly cost.
That is the annual labour cost of the task as it runs today. The next question is what share an automation would remove, and that is the number to be most careful with.
What is a fully loaded hourly cost?
It is the “£?” on Linda’s envelope. Salary is not what a person costs. On top of pay, an employer pays National Insurance contributions, pension contributions and holiday, and provides a desk, a computer, software licences and a share of the building. The fully loaded hourly cost is all of that, divided by the hours actually worked.
For a cost anchor, sales order processor roles in Hull were advertised in 2025 at £12.21 to £15 an hour (Michael Page, Adecco) and at £25,350 to £26,350 a year for permanent posts. Glassdoor puts the UK average for the role at about £21,642 a year (Glassdoor).
In the worked example below Linda writes £20 an hour. That is a labelled assumption, above the advertised hourly rates to allow for what an employer pays on top of wages, and round so the arithmetic is easy to follow. Your accountant can give you the real figure in a few minutes, and you should use it.
What is the difference between capacity released and cash saved?
The formula gives you the value of hours. It does not give you cash. The hours come back to the business as money only if you change what you pay for, and there are three common ways that happens:
- A leaver is not replaced.
- Overtime, temp cover or agency staff stop being needed.
- A hire you were planning is not made.
Two of those are live for Linda. She signs Sandra’s overtime every week, and she cannot fill the second order processor’s job. Overtime she stops paying is cash. So is a salary she never starts paying.
If none of those happens, the hours are still real, but they are capacity. The order desk handles more orders without growing, or spends the time on credit control, chasing proofs of delivery and answering customers. That is worth having, and for a growing wholesaler it is often the whole point. It shows up as growth without taking anyone on, not as a smaller wage bill. A competitor whose order desk no longer types can accept an order emailed at 9pm and have it ready to approve when the office opens. We go into what this means for the people on the order desk in Will automation replace our office staff?.
Write your business case with both figures. Capacity value is the formula result. Cash saving is the part you have a plan to turn into money.
What does the worked example look like?
Here is Linda’s envelope written out in full. Every number is an assumption, chosen to be plausible for a mid-sized wholesaler and easy to check. Replace each one with your own.
| Assumption | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Orders typed in by hand each week | 300 | A typical week, counted |
| Minutes to type in one order | 4 | Timed from opening the email to saving the sales order |
| Working weeks a year | 48 | Allows for holidays and bank holidays |
| Fully loaded hourly cost | £20 | Above advertised Hull rates to allow for costs on top of wages |
| Share of typing time removed by automation | 70% | Upper end; applies only inside this example |
| Result | Calculation | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Hours a year spent typing in orders | 300 × 4 ÷ 60 × 48 | 960 hours |
| Annual labour cost of typing | 960 × £20 | £19,200 |
| Hours removed at 70% | 960 × 0.7 | 672 hours |
| Value of hours removed | 672 × £20 | £13,440 a year |
| Hours still needed for approving and for orders that need a person | 960 − 672 | 288 hours |
So the envelope reads £19,200 a year. In Sandra’s week, 20 hours of typing become about 6 hours of checking and approving, and 14 hours come back.
The 70% is not a promise. It is the upper end of what is plausible when most orders arrive as readable emails, PDFs or spreadsheets, and when Sandra spends the remaining time approving orders on a screen and not typing them. A business where half the orders come in by phone would see a smaller share, because the phone call still needs a person. An automation audit measures the share on your real orders before you commit to anything.
What other value is there beyond keying time?
Typing time is the easiest value to count. Four others often matter more. Each needs a baseline, a figure for how things stand today, before you can put it in pounds.
- Errors and rework. Wrong quantities, wrong products, a case typed in as a single. Each one costs a pick, a delivery and a correction. Baseline: count the corrections in a month and what each one cost in time and carriage.
- Credit notes. Many credit notes trace back to a typing error. Baseline: pull three months of credit notes from your accounts system and mark the reason for each.
- Quote speed. If the people who type in orders also build quotes, the hours handed back turn into faster quotes. Baseline: enquiries received, quotes sent and days to quote, which we cover in automating quotations from your Excel price list.
- Overdue invoices. An order entered late is invoiced late and paid late. Baseline: your debtor days, the average time customers take to pay, and how many invoices went out more than a day after despatch.
The rule is simple. If you have the baseline, put the number in the business case and label it. If you do not, write “not yet measured” and leave it out of the total. A business case that claims savings it cannot show is how software projects get a bad name.
How do I work out the payback?
Payback in months = build cost ÷ (annual value ÷ 12). On Linda’s envelope the annual value is £13,440, which is £1,120 a month.
| Better Systems Co. price band | Build cost | Payback on £13,440 a year |
|---|---|---|
| Quick win | £1,500 to £3,000 | 1.3 to 2.7 months |
| Business workflow | £3,000 to £7,500 | 2.7 to 6.7 months |
| Operations automation | £7,500 to £15,000 and above | 6.7 to 13.4 months and above |
Emailed orders going into one system usually sit in the quick win band. Orders arriving several ways, or two systems to feed, push the job into the business workflow band. The pricing page sets out what each covers.
Two adjustments keep the figure honest. First, the audit fee of £500 to £1,250 is credited against the build, so it does not add to the cost if you go ahead. Second, if you take a managed support plan at £150 to £1,500 a month, subtract its annual cost from the annual value before you divide. At £250 a month, another labelled assumption, the net value becomes £10,440 a year and a £7,500 build pays back in about 8.6 months.
If the payback runs beyond two years on your numbers, volumes are probably too low, or a cheaper fix exists, such as an import feature already in your system that nobody switched on. For eligible manufacturers in Yorkshire and the Humber, a Made Smarter grant can change the arithmetic.
What changes for Linda and Sandra afterwards?
Same office, same 300 orders, same assumptions. When Sandra sits down, most of the morning’s emailed orders are already drafted as sales orders, each beside the email it came from. She checks and approves them. Any the software was unsure about wait for her, and the phone orders are still hers. She still knows every customer’s cut-off and minimum order, and has 14 more hours a week to use what she knows.
Linda’s part is deciding what the 14 hours are for. If they end the overtime, that is cash. If they let the order desk grow without the second hire, she takes the advert down. The rest is capacity, and her business case says which is which.
What we would do
We would count, where Linda could only reckon. In an Automation Opportunity Audit we watch real orders being typed in, time them, count a typical week, and work out the fully loaded cost with your accountant. We then measure what share of 50 to 100 of your real orders software could read and match, and put the sums in front of you in pounds with every assumption labelled. The fee is credited against a build, and the report says so plainly if the numbers do not justify one. The ROI calculator lets you do a first pass on your own before that conversation.
Sources
- Sage Community Hub, thread 117718, “Purchase and sales orders”: https://communityhub.sage.com/gb/sage-50-accounts/f/general-discussion-uk/117718/purchase-and-sales-orders
- Sage Community Hub, thread 203817, “Importing sales orders/invoices”: https://communityhub.sage.com/gb/sage-50-accounts/f/general-discussion-uk/203817/importing-sales-orders-invoices
- Michael Page, Sales Order Processor, Hull (2025): https://www.michaelpage.co.uk/job-detail/sales-order-processor/ref/jn-032025-6697236
- Adecco, Order Processor, Hull and East Riding (2025): https://www.adecco.com/en-gb/job-search/order-processor-mk058-hull-east-riding-of-yorkshire/broadbean_644851779190287
- Glassdoor, Sales Order Processor salaries, UK: https://www.glassdoor.co.uk/Salaries/sales-order-processor-salary-SRCH_KO0,21.htm
- Sage, “The £31bn tech tangle” (23 September 2026): https://www.sage.com/en-gb/company/digital-newsroom/2026/09/the-31bn-tech-tangle-smes-lose-19-working-days-a-year-making-digital-tools-work-together/
- Made Smarter Yorkshire and the Humber: https://www.madesmarter.uk/adoption/in-my-region/yorkshire-the-humber/
Questions people ask
What hourly cost should I use if I do not know our fully loaded figure?
Ask your accountant or payroll provider for salary plus employer's National Insurance, pension contributions and holiday cost, divided by hours worked. If you need a figure today, start from the advertised Hull rates of £12.21 to £15 an hour for a sales order processor and add what you pay on top of wages. Label whatever you use as an assumption and replace it when you have the real number.
Should I count the time of the owner or a manager who also keys orders?
Yes, and at their cost, not the order desk rate. An hour of a director typing in orders is an hour not spent on customers, suppliers or pricing. Many wholesalers find that the most expensive person in the building covers the order desk on busy days, which is exactly the time that automation returns first.
Is a 70% reduction in keying time realistic for us?
It is a labelled assumption in our worked example, not a forecast for your business. The share depends on how many of your orders arrive in readable written form, how consistent each customer's format is, and how many need a judgement call. We measure the share on your real orders in the audit before anyone spends money on a build.
Does the ROI change if our order volume grows?
Yes. Manual entry cost rises in step with orders, because each extra order needs the same minutes. The cost of an automation does not rise in the same way once it is built. If you expect volumes to grow, run the formula at today's volume and at the volume you expect in two years, and look at both results.